--- title: "What’s a Supervisor? The Supreme Court Could Decide" id: "14561" type: "post" slug: "whats-a-supervisor-the-supreme-court-could-decide" published_at: "2012-11-26T19:52:32+00:00" modified_at: "2026-11-09T19:19:53+00:00" url: "https://associationsnow.com/2012/11/26/whats-a-supervisor-the-supreme-court-could-decide/" markdown_url: "https://associationsnow.com/2012/11/26/whats-a-supervisor-the-supreme-court-could-decide.md" excerpt: "On Monday, the court heard arguments in the case of a Ball State University employee who faced harassment from her coworkers — one of whom she claimed was a supervisor." taxonomy_category: - "Advocacy" taxonomy_post_tag: - "AssociationsNow" - "Business" - "discrimination" - "employment law" - "Supreme Court" taxonomy_content_format: - "Article" taxonomy_role: - "Association CEO / Executive Director" - "C-Level" - "Executive Team" taxonomy_persona: - "Executive Leadership" --- [Home](https://associationsnow.com/) » [Articles](https://associationsnow.com/format/article/) » What’s a Supervisor? The Supreme Court Could Decide Based on a case currently on the docket, the Supreme Court could redefine decades of employment-discrimination law. The case, *Vance v. Ball State University*, could broaden the definition of what constitutes a supervisor — potentially opening up associations, businesses, and other groups to new lawsuits while giving affected employees more leverage. The court heard arguments in the case Monday. More details: **The case in question:** A former Ball State University catering worker, Maetta Vance, says she was long subject to racially motivated harassment during her employment with the university. Vance was the only black employee at the time and complained to her employer about the situation for years — citing one coworker in particular, Saundra Davis, who Vance claims was in a supervisory role — before filing a lawsuit in 2006. > The expanded definition of whose conduct binds the employer will significantly increase litigation for employers. **Why it’s important for associations:** The case could have a strong effect on employment discrimination laws, based on the Supreme Court’s decision, by offering a stronger definition of “supervisor” in the legal sense. Lower court decisions in the case have been split. The 7th Circuit Court ruled that a supervisor is only someone who can directly cause workplace action, such as hiring, firing, and promotions. However, lower courts have ruled that direct reports who work closely with the employee also count as supervisors. “The expanded definition of whose conduct binds the employer will significantly increase litigation for employers,” [lawyer Camille Olson told Reuters (opens in a new tab)](http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/23/us-usa-court-harassment-idUSBRE8AM0JX20121123) . **Where associations stand:** [According to SCOTUSblog (opens in a new tab)](http://www.scotusblog.com/2012/11/argument-preview-who-is-a-supervisor/) , both sides have backing from a number of industry groups. Vance’s *amici* support includes the AARP and the National Association of Employment Lawyers, among civil rights and employee rights organizations. Meanwhile, Ball State University has the backing of a larger number of industry groups, including big players such as the National Retail Federation and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. **How the case could turn:** While the federal government sees this as a serious issue, when the Supreme Court asked the U.S. Solicitor General to present its stance, the government suggested that Vance’s claims of Davis being her supervisor were weak — though it encouraged the Supreme Court to create a stronger standard that Vance and her attorneys could use in re-arguing her case at a lower court level. Ball State University, meanwhile, attempted to dissuade the high court from taking on the case, arguing that previous legal precedent didn’t match Vance’s specific situation. While the Supreme Court has previously passed on similar cases, however, they took on Vance’s — suggesting a precedent could be made. Where does your association stand on this issue? Let us know in the comments. (Comstock/Thinkstock) [Ernie Smith](https://associationsnow.com/author/ernie-smith/) Ernie Smith is a former senior editor for Associations Now. [More articles by this author](https://associationsnow.com/author/ernie-smith/) Tags: [#Business](https://associationsnow.com/tag/business/) [#discrimination](https://associationsnow.com/tag/discrimination/) [#employment law](https://associationsnow.com/tag/employment-law/) [#Supreme Court](https://associationsnow.com/tag/supreme-court/) **Stay Informed** [Subscribe to our free newsletter](https://associationsnow.com/newsletter/) , *Associations Now Daily News*, to find out what’s happening in the association world every business day. ## You Might Like - [VideoASAE ‘Power of A’ DOL Program on the DOL Overtime RuleJune 30, 2016](https://associationsnow.com/2016/06/30/asae-power-of-a-dol-program-on-the-dol-overtime-rule/) - [VideoOvertime rule promo June 23 eventJune 17, 2016](https://associationsnow.com/2016/06/17/overtime-rule-promo-june-23-event/) - [VideoThe Career Moves Every Association Leader Needs Right NowSeptember 24, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/09/24/the-career-moves-every-association-leader-needs-right-now/) - [VideoUrban Land Institute- Project Recovery: Rebuilding Los Angeles After the January 2025 WildfiresSeptember 24, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/09/24/urban-land-institute-project-recovery-rebuilding-los-angeles-after-the-january-2025-wildfires/) ## Comments **Comments are for ASAE members.** [Learn more about comments on this site.](https://associationsnow.com/comments/) [Log in](https://associationsnow.com/login?redirect_to=https%3A%2F%2Fassociationsnow.com%2F2012%2F11%2F26%2Fwhats-a-supervisor-the-supreme-court-could-decide%2F%23comments) to your member account or [join ASAE](https://my.asaecenter.org/select-a-membership-type/) !