--- title: "New York Sheriffs: Federal Immigration Detainers Aren’t Enough" id: "24505" type: "post" slug: "new-york-sheriffs-federal-immigration-detainers-arent-enough" published_at: "2014-08-05T18:22:23+00:00" modified_at: "2026-03-16T12:30:46+00:00" url: "https://associationsnow.com/2014/08/05/new-york-sheriffs-federal-immigration-detainers-arent-enough/" markdown_url: "https://associationsnow.com/2014/08/05/new-york-sheriffs-federal-immigration-detainers-arent-enough.md" excerpt: "With a mounting number of rulings stating that holding someone who has been arrested and jailed for extra time to allow for an immigration check is a Fourth Amendment violation, the New York State Sheriffs' Association has encouraged its members..." taxonomy_category: - "Advocacy" taxonomy_post_tag: - "AssociationsNow" - "civil liberties" - "immigration reform" - "Law Enforcement" - "Leadership" taxonomy_content_format: - "Article" taxonomy_role: - "Director" - "Manager" taxonomy_persona: - "Executive Leadership" --- [Home](https://associationsnow.com/) » [Articles](https://associationsnow.com/format/article/) » New York Sheriffs: Federal Immigration Detainers Aren’t Enough In a move that some say could disrupt federal immigration enforcement, the New York State Sheriffs’ Association is urging its members not to honor requests by federal immigration officials to hold foreign-born detainees for additional time to allow for an immigration status check. The association’s recommendation, which at least nine New York sheriffs have said they would honor, was spurred partly by pressure from the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU), which argues that such detentions violate the Fourth Amendment. The move, which was first reported by [The New York Times last Wednesday (opens in a new tab)](http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/31/nyregion/new-york-state-sheriffs-shying-away-from-immigration-detention-.html) , follows a wave of federal court decisions that have raised questions about whether it’s legal to honor an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainer. > No New Yorker should ever be imprisoned unless there is a warrant for his arrest or a judge has reviewed his case. In an email obtained by the *Times*, the association’s associate counsel, Alex Wilson, noted that federal detainer requests were just that—requests, not mandates—meaning they’re not enough on their own to hold a person longer than allowed for the original legal infraction. “[J]ail inmates who are held in custody solely by virtue of an ICE detainer are being held illegally, in violation of their Fourth Amendment rights protecting them from unreasonable searches and seizures,” Wilson wrote in the email. NYCLU Executive Director Donna Lieberman agrees. “A foundational principle of our country is the right to due process. No New Yorker should ever be imprisoned unless there is a warrant for his arrest or a judge has reviewed his case,” [Lieberman said in a statement (opens in a new tab)](http://www.nyclu.org/news/ny-sheriffs-stop-unlawfully-jailing-immigrants-thanks-nyclu-advocacy) , adding that she applauded the sheriffs’ association’s recommendation and that “nobody should be imprisoned based on a hunch.” Even before the state organization spoke up, some sheriffs’ departments were disregarding the detainers individually, unless they came with a warrant. < p>”It didn’t cut the mustard with us,” Estseban Gonzalez, who leads the Onondaga County Sheriff’s Office’s custody department, [told Syracuse.com (opens in a new tab)](http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2014/07/some_cny_sheriffs_tell_the_feds_no_on_keeping_immigration_violators_for_extra_ti.html) . (photo by John Moore/Getty Images) [Ernie Smith](https://associationsnow.com/author/ernie-smith/) Ernie Smith is a former senior editor for Associations Now. [More articles by this author](https://associationsnow.com/author/ernie-smith/) Tags: [#civil liberties](https://associationsnow.com/tag/civil-liberties/) [#immigration reform](https://associationsnow.com/tag/immigration-reform/) [#Law Enforcement](https://associationsnow.com/tag/law-enforcement/) [#Leadership](https://associationsnow.com/tag/leadership/) **Stay Informed** [Subscribe to our free newsletter](https://associationsnow.com/newsletter/) , *Associations Now Daily News*, to find out what’s happening in the association world every business day. ## You Might Like - [VideoThe Career Moves Every Association Leader Needs Right NowSeptember 24, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/09/24/the-career-moves-every-association-leader-needs-right-now/) - [VideoUrban Land Institute- Project Recovery: Rebuilding Los Angeles After the January 2025 WildfiresSeptember 24, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/09/24/urban-land-institute-project-recovery-rebuilding-los-angeles-after-the-january-2025-wildfires/) - [VideoNCRA: Safeguarding Cancer Surveillance: An Advocacy Response to FY26 Budget ThreatsSeptember 24, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/09/24/ncra-safeguarding-cancer-surveillance-an-advocacy-response-to-fy26-budget-threats/) - [VideoASAE Legislative Summit 2026March 26, 2026](https://associationsnow.com/2026/03/26/asae-legislative-summit-2026/) ## Comments **Comments are for ASAE members.** [Learn more about comments on this site.](https://associationsnow.com/comments/) [Log in](https://associationsnow.com/login?redirect_to=https%3A%2F%2Fassociationsnow.com%2F2014%2F08%2F05%2Fnew-york-sheriffs-federal-immigration-detainers-arent-enough%2F%23comments) to your member account or [join ASAE](https://my.asaecenter.org/select-a-membership-type/) !