Skip to content

Article Marketing / Communications Meetings / Events 5 min read

Fans Beat Followers, Even in Associations

When it comes to member engagement, the size of a crowd and the depth of its support are two very different things.

For 20 years, I worked in media, and for most of that time the work centered on the question, “How many?” How many viewers, views, listens, and listeners—latterly, how many followers. 

For most of those years, numbers were all that mattered. A broadcaster set the table, the audience sat down at 9 p.m., and everyone tucked into the same thing. It was very orderly. The numbers were reported each week, and if they had gone up, it was off to the pub. 

Reach Was the Scoreboard. That Scoreboard Has Broken. 

Audiences now watch what they want, when they want, on whatever screen is closest. They gather in their own corners, in Reddit threads and WhatsApp group chats. The broadcaster no longer owns the room. At a Royal Television Society’s event this year, media commentator Evan Shapiro put it simply: “Fandom is going to surpass reach.” The industry is moving “from vanity metrics to engagement metrics.” 

Now I spend my time with associations, and I see the same shift. Members can connect on their own terms, on their own platforms, in special-interest groups the association didn’t set up and may not know exist. AI is speeding this up by changing how people find information, find each other, and decide where their attention goes. 

So, if members can find their people without you, why would they pay to ‘belong’? 

It’s clearly a big worry. In ASAE’s “State of Associations” report, retention and engagement ranked at the top of association leaders’ challenges, according to nearly a third of respondents. 

The media world is learning a lesson that associations should pay attention to: Fans beat followers. 

What’s the Difference? 

The Oxford dictionary defines fandom as “the fans of a particular person, team, TV show, etc. considered together as a community.” The important word there is community. Fandom isn’t only about how one person feels, it’s about belonging to a group of people who feel the same way. 

A follower is something different. In its modern sense it’s a digital term describing someone who has clicked a button to follow you on social media. That takes one second and costs nothing. A follower will see your post if the algorithm allows it and will float away just as easily. 

Fan behavior is different. I’ve held a Spurs (Tottenham Hotspur) season ticket through more ‘crises’ than I care to count. Of course I have threatened to stop going. Of course, I never have or would. That loyalty isn’t based on the results.  A follower watches the results; a fan feels invested in them and stays whatever the outcome. 

Associations Have the Raw Material for Fandom 

As an Associations Now article (opens in a new tab) on member engagement put it recently, “the core value proposition hasn’t changed—”networking, education, belonging” are still in demand. People love the annual conference. They love the shared experience with their peer community. You could see all of that at ASAE Annual in Indianapolis this August. More than 5,000 people registered, and 500 of them volunteered to help run it. A hallmark of fandom is people who don’t just attend but take part. 

So, should we focus on the real fans? Find the members who really connect and look after them. A TV producer I know used to say: “I like to make the show for the 30 people that will really love it and the rest will follow.” Associations know who their 30 are. 

That is perhaps a strength that comes with a risk: 

Your organization can end up being led by a small group. Every association has an inner circle. They’re precious, but listen only to them and the association starts to reflect their priorities rather than the industry’s. Newer, younger, and quieter members stop seeing themselves in it, and they stop joining. Bands that only play the deep cuts end up in smaller rooms. 

The job is bigger than looking after your fans. It’s turning followers into fans. 

I was taught that when creating any type of content you should consider three things: reach, relevance, and resonance. Reach the right people, give them something worth keeping, and leave a lasting impact. 

That works just as well for associations. 

  • Reach. Use the channels your audience actually uses and make things easy to share. That means going where members already gather rather than waiting for them to come to you. 
  • Relevance. Make something your audience truly values by tapping into what only your community can offer—the people, the expertise, and ability to connect in one place. 
  • Resonance. Create a lasting impact and make viewers think, feel or do something. Renewal is the minimum; active participation is the real prize. 

Resonance Starts With Listening 

Ask members what they care about, then show them what you heard. The ASAE Research Foundation’s Innovation Impact Study  (opens in a new tab) found that association members recognize innovation, and that in turn improves participation. We saw an association partner using Natter’s AI platform at their recent conference, and just the act of listening to perspectives increased members’ sense of belonging and engagement. 

In 2025, official “Love Island” clips drew 9.7 billion views online. Fan-made videos with “Love Island” hashtags received 49.3 billion, five times as many. And ITV lets it run. Give people a role, a say, and a way in, and they start to feel like they belong. People become fans of the things they’ve helped shape. 

The associations that thrive will be the ones that stop counting followers and start creating fans—the people who turn up, take part, and feel like they’re shaping the community.

Simon Shelley

Simon Shelley

Simon Shelley is vice president at Natter.

More articles by this author

Tags: #Member Engagement

Comments

Comments are for ASAE members. Learn more about comments on this site.

Log in to your member account or join ASAE!